A hidden detention facility, allegations of torture, disappearing prisoners and a legal battle that exposed one of Israel’s most controversial military installations.
- The discovery of a secret prison
- Inside the facility
- The prisoners: Hezbollah, Lebanon and Palestine
- The numbers: How many people were detained?
- Allegations of torture and psychological abuse
- The Israeli Supreme Court becomes involved
- What did the United Nations conclude?
- Did Facility 1391 actually close?
- The wider significance: Can a democracy operate a secret prison?
- What remains unanswered?
- The Blurs perspective
- Sources and further investigation
For decades, a military detention facility existed somewhere in northern Israel that was largely absent from public maps, inaccessible to ordinary prison inspectors and unknown to much of the Israeli public. Its existence was eventually exposed through the efforts of human-rights lawyers attempting to locate people who had effectively disappeared after being detained by Israeli security forces.
Known as Facility 1391, the installation became internationally notorious for allegations of psychological torture, prolonged isolation, abusive interrogation and the detention of individuals whose whereabouts were concealed from their families.
Sometimes described as Israel’s equivalent of Guantanamo Bay, the facility raises uncomfortable questions about national security, secret detention, judicial oversight and the treatment of prisoners during periods of military conflict.
But what actually happened inside Facility 1391? Who was held there? Why was it kept secret, and what became of it?
The discovery of a secret prison
Facility 1391 was not a conventional prison hidden behind an ordinary security perimeter. Its existence was concealed to such an extent that information about its location, activities and prisoners was tightly restricted.
The facility was reportedly established inside a former British Mandate-era military fort, constructed during the 1930s as part of a network of fortified police stations designed to maintain British control over Palestine.
The building was subsequently incorporated into an Israeli military installation associated with intelligence operations. Its precise location became the subject of considerable controversy. Investigative reporting identified it as being in northern Israel, in the general area between Hadera and Afula. Human-rights organisation HaMoked subsequently described it as a former British fort near Hadera.
The facility reportedly operated for many years without its existence being publicly acknowledged.
Although its history extends further back, Facility 1391 entered international consciousness in 2002 and 2003, when lawyers attempting to locate missing Palestinian detainees began uncovering evidence that people were being held at an undisclosed military installation.
During Israel’s 2002 military operation in the West Bank, known as Operation Defensive Shield, thousands of Palestinians were detained. Families seeking information about relatives encountered difficulties establishing where they had been taken.
HaMoked, the Israeli Centre for the Defence of the Individual, began pursuing legal action to establish the whereabouts of several missing detainees. During these investigations, information emerged about a secret detention facility administered by the Israeli military.
The authorities were eventually forced to acknowledge that Facility 1391 existed. The revelation demonstrated that individuals could be transferred into a detention system whose location was not disclosed to their families, lawyers or external monitoring organisations.
Inside the facility
Some of the most disturbing information about Facility 1391 comes from testimonies provided by former detainees and subsequently documented by investigative journalists and human-rights organisations.
In November 2003, The Guardian published an extensive investigation by journalist Chris McGreal, entitled Facility 1391: Israel’s secret prison. The report described an installation surrounded by substantial security infrastructure, including reinforced fencing and watchtowers.
Former prisoners described being transported blindfolded, sometimes with their hands and feet restrained. On arrival, they were reportedly instructed to wear black hoods whenever guards entered their cells or delivered food. Some detainees were allegedly told they were outside Israel, on a submarine, in Honolulu or even on the moon.
Descriptions of the cells were particularly disturbing. Former detainees reported:
- Small, windowless cells with dark-painted walls.
- Poor lighting and limited access to natural daylight.
- Continuous mechanical noise from ventilation systems.
- Thin mattresses placed on concrete platforms.
- Inadequate sanitation, including the use of buckets as toilets.
- Restricted access to washing facilities and clean clothing.
- Prolonged periods of solitary confinement.
- Sleep deprivation and psychological pressure.
One former detainee described spending approximately 67 days in solitary confinement. He alleged that interrogators deliberately prevented him from sleeping for more than two hours at a time.
These accounts were not simply allegations about uncomfortable prison conditions. They raised serious questions about whether the facility was being used to facilitate interrogation methods that would otherwise attract greater scrutiny.
It is important to distinguish between the testimonies of former prisoners, the allegations made in legal proceedings and findings independently established by courts or official investigations. Not every reported incident has been independently verified. Nevertheless, the consistency of several accounts attracted international attention.
The prisoners: Hezbollah, Lebanon and Palestine
Facility 1391 reportedly served several different purposes during its history. It was associated with Israeli military intelligence and the interrogation of individuals considered particularly valuable from an intelligence perspective.
Among those detained were Lebanese nationals captured during Israel’s military involvement in southern Lebanon, Palestinian detainees and individuals suspected of involvement in intelligence or militant organisations.
Sheikh Abdul Karim Obeid
In July 1989, Israeli commandos abducted Sheikh Abdul Karim Obeid from his home in southern Lebanon. Obeid was a prominent religious figure associated with Hezbollah.
His capture formed part of a broader strategy involving the detention of Lebanese individuals who might potentially be exchanged for captured Israeli personnel. Obeid was subsequently held in Israeli custody, including at Facility 1391 according to published accounts.
Mustafa Dirani
In May 1994, Israeli forces abducted Mustafa Dirani from Lebanon. Dirani was associated with the Amal movement and had been involved in the detention of Israeli airman Ron Arad, whose aircraft was shot down over Lebanon in 1986.
Israel hoped that capturing Dirani might provide information about Arad’s whereabouts. Dirani was subsequently detained in Israel for years.
He later alleged that he had suffered sexual abuse and torture during interrogation. His allegations included claims that an interrogator, identified as Major George, had threatened and subjected him to sexual violence.
The Israeli authorities denied that Dirani had been raped. However, subsequent reporting revealed that a military police investigation had identified suspicions that an interrogator had threatened to commit a sexual act against him. The interrogator was reportedly dismissed.
The episode became one of the most disturbing aspects of the Facility 1391 controversy.
The Lebanese hostages
The detention of Lebanese nationals was also connected to Israel’s attempts to secure the release of missing Israeli personnel. In some cases, individuals were held for years without being convicted of an offence.
One particularly striking case involved Hashem Fahaf, who was abducted during the operation against Obeid. He reportedly spent approximately 11 years in Israeli custody despite never being accused of a crime.
Israel eventually acknowledged that it had held Lebanese prisoners as bargaining leverage in the effort to obtain information about Ron Arad. This raised an important distinction between detention for criminal investigation and detention intended to provide strategic leverage in negotiations.
The numbers: How many people were detained?
One of the most revealing documents in the investigation is a letter submitted by Israel’s State Attorney’s Office on 2 December 2004 during legal proceedings brought by HaMoked.
According to the government’s own figures, 271 detainees were held at the facility between 1993 and 2004.
Of these, 158 were held between April 2002 and March 2003, when the facility was made available to the General Security Service following Operation Defensive Shield. The remaining 113 detainees were held during the wider 12-year period.
The government also provided information about detention periods. Its submission stated that before 1997, administrative detainees could be held for several months. After 1997, the facility was generally used for interrogation purposes. Most subsequent detainees were held for no more than 30 days, while four individuals in the relevant group were held for 54 days.
The figures move the discussion beyond speculation. The Israeli authorities themselves acknowledged that hundreds of people had passed through the facility.
However, the figures did not provide a complete historical record. Information relating to periods before 1993 was not readily available, and the government did not disclose all detainees’ identities or the reasons for their detention. The full scale of the facility’s historical operations therefore remains uncertain.
Allegations of torture and psychological abuse
The allegations surrounding Facility 1391 eventually attracted the attention of United Nations investigators.
In 2005, the UN Special Rapporteur on torture documented allegations concerning the installation. The material submitted to the Special Rapporteur described prisoners being held incommunicado, denied access to lawyers and relatives, and subjected to severe psychological and physical mistreatment.
Reported practices included prolonged isolation, sleep deprivation, threats of sexual violence, physical assaults, forced nudity, humiliation and intimidation, inadequate sanitation and threats involving family members.
Some accounts described particularly degrading treatment during interrogation. The allegations were serious enough to become the subject of international scrutiny.
However, Israel disputed the characterisation of the facility and maintained that its detention conditions were consistent with those in other military detention establishments. The government also stated that allegations of torture and mistreatment had been investigated and that there were insufficient grounds for criminal proceedings against members of the facility’s staff.
This disagreement became central to the subsequent legal battle.
The Israeli Supreme Court becomes involved
The existence of Facility 1391 presented a difficult legal question. Israel maintained that the facility operated under military authority and that the rights of detainees remained protected by law. Human-rights organisations argued that concealing the location of a detention facility undermined some of the most basic protections available to prisoners.
If families did not know where someone was being held, how could they reliably establish their whereabouts? If lawyers could not visit the facility, how could they properly represent their clients? And if independent organisations were prevented from inspecting the premises, how could allegations of abuse be investigated effectively?
In 2005, the Israeli Supreme Court rejected petitions challenging the authorities’ decision not to open more extensive criminal investigations into allegations of abuse at the facility.
The court did not conduct a comprehensive independent investigation into every allegation. Instead, it accepted that the authorities had acted within their discretion when deciding not to pursue criminal proceedings.
The controversy continued. In January 2011, the Supreme Court issued another important judgment in proceedings brought by HaMoked and Knesset member Zehava Gal-On. The petition sought greater transparency, including disclosure of the facility’s location and permission for parliamentary representatives to inspect it.
The court dismissed the petition. However, the judgment accepted arrangements put forward by the state that substantially restricted the facility’s future use.
- Residents of Israel and the occupied Palestinian territories would not be detained there.
- Other individuals could only be held for an extremely limited period.
- Detention would require high-level authorisation.
- The Attorney General would have to be informed.
Some of the arrangements remained classified. Consequently, the public could not independently examine every safeguard that the authorities claimed had been introduced.
The decision was controversial because it effectively allowed the facility to remain part of the state’s classified military infrastructure, while imposing restrictions on its use.
What did the United Nations conclude?
The UN Committee Against Torture examined the controversy as part of its scrutiny of Israel’s compliance with the Convention Against Torture.
Israel informed the committee that Facility 1391 had not been used to detain or interrogate security suspects since 2006. The government also maintained that allegations of abuse had been investigated and that no grounds for criminal proceedings had been established.
However, the committee expressed serious concern. It specifically criticised the rejection of petitions seeking examination of the facility and the authorities’ handling of allegations involving torture, mistreatment and poor detention conditions.
Its recommendations included ensuring that no secret detention facilities were used in the future, investigating and disclosing the existence of any other such facilities, ensuring allegations of torture and mistreatment at Facility 1391 were impartially investigated, publishing the results and holding anyone responsible for breaches of the Convention accountable.
The committee also made clear that secret detention centres are inherently incompatible with the Convention Against Torture. This was an important international assessment, although it should not be confused with a criminal court finding that every allegation made against Facility 1391 had been proven.
Did Facility 1391 actually close?
This is where the story becomes particularly interesting.
Israel stated that the facility had not held detainees since September 2006. That statement is important, but it does not necessarily mean the physical installation was closed, demolished or permanently decommissioned.
There is a distinction between a detention facility no longer being used to hold prisoners and the military installation itself ceasing to exist. The 2011 Supreme Court proceedings also demonstrate that the government continued to treat Facility 1391 as an installation subject to classified restrictions rather than simply acknowledging its permanent closure.
The publicly available record does not establish that the building was demolished or that its military infrastructure was dismantled. Nor does it establish that another facility replaced it.
As of November 2026, there is no reliable, independently verified evidence demonstrating that Facility 1391 has resumed detention operations. Equally, the historical record does not provide sufficient transparency to establish precisely what happened to the installation after the government reported that detention had ceased.
Its present physical condition, ownership and operational status remain matters requiring further investigation.
The wider significance: Can a democracy operate a secret prison?
Facility 1391 raises questions that extend well beyond Israel. Governments routinely classify military installations, intelligence operations and sensitive information. There are legitimate reasons for protecting intelligence sources and operational security.
However, detention introduces a different set of responsibilities. International law requires detainees to receive fundamental protections. These include safeguards against torture, arbitrary detention and enforced disappearance.
Concealing the location of prisoners creates obvious difficulties for independent oversight. It can also make it harder for families to establish whether someone is alive, where they are being held and whether they have access to legal representation.
The problem is not simply whether a government has the authority to operate a secure interrogation facility. It is whether that authority can be exercised without effective external scrutiny.
Facility 1391 demonstrated how national security arguments can collide with fundamental human rights. It also exposed an uncomfortable contradiction: a government can formally recognise the rights of detainees while maintaining an institution in which those rights become considerably harder to monitor.
What remains unanswered?
More than two decades after the facility became internationally known, several questions remain unresolved.
What happened before 1993? The Israeli government’s own figures acknowledged that earlier detention records were not readily available. The complete historical number of prisoners is therefore unknown.
Who were all the detainees? The government disclosed aggregate figures but did not provide a complete public list of names, nationalities and detention circumstances.
Were all allegations properly investigated? The authorities maintained that investigations had taken place. Human-rights organisations and the UN Committee Against Torture questioned whether the process was sufficiently thorough and independent.
What happened to the installation after 2006? Israel stated that detention had ceased, but the publicly available evidence does not establish that the physical facility was permanently closed or dismantled.
Does another equivalent facility exist? There is no reliable public evidence establishing that Facility 1391 was replaced by another secret prison. Nevertheless, the UN Committee Against Torture explicitly called on Israel to disclose whether other secret detention facilities existed.
That recommendation highlights the underlying problem: secrecy makes independent verification exceptionally difficult.
The Blurs perspective
Facility 1391 is not simply a story about an obscure military prison. It is a documented example of how a detention facility can operate outside ordinary public scrutiny for years, with its existence eventually exposed through the efforts of lawyers searching for missing prisoners.
The Israeli government acknowledged the facility, disclosed figures showing that hundreds of people had been detained there and subsequently stated that it had stopped holding prisoners in 2006.
But acknowledging that a facility exists is not the same as providing full accountability for what happened inside it.
The allegations of torture, the use of Lebanese prisoners as bargaining leverage, the detention of Palestinians whose whereabouts were concealed and the refusal to permit independent access all raise serious questions.
The Supreme Court’s decisions provided a degree of legal oversight, but the classified nature of the arrangements limited public transparency.
Perhaps the most important lesson is that national security cannot become a blanket justification for removing individuals from meaningful legal protection.
A prison does not cease to require scrutiny simply because the government classifies its location.
And when the people responsible for detention also control the information available about the conditions inside, independent investigation becomes more important, not less.
Facility 1391 may no longer be holding prisoners. But the questions surrounding its history, the treatment of its detainees and the extent of official accountability remain relevant.
Sources and further investigation
- The Guardian (2003): Facility 1391: Israel’s secret prison — investigative reporting based on former detainees’ accounts.
- HaMoked: Supreme Court judgment, 20 January 2011 — legal proceedings concerning the facility and its future use.
- Israeli State Attorney’s Office (2004): Official disclosure of detainee numbers and detention periods — the government’s own figures.
- UN Committee Against Torture: Concluding observations on Israel — international concerns and recommendations.
- UN Special Rapporteur on torture (2005) — report documenting allegations concerning Facility 1391.
- HaMoked: Background to the discovery of Facility 1391.
