What if humans were deliberately using mind-altering plants thousands of years before farming, permanent settlements or the first known alcoholic drinks?
Archaeological evidence from the Indonesian island of Sulawesi suggests that people may have been using a psychoactive plant as far back as 25,000 years ago. The evidence comes not from a written record, a ceremonial object or a preserved stash of plants. It comes from human teeth.
A strange pattern in ancient teeth
Researchers examining prehistoric human remains from Sulawesi identified unusual patterns of dental wear: deep, rounded grooves and extensive damage that may be difficult to explain through ordinary eating alone.
The older individual lived sometime between approximately 25,000 and 16,000 years ago, during the last Ice Age. A second individual, thousands of years younger, showed a similar pattern. The researchers proposed that the wear could have resulted from repeatedly holding or sucking hard, abrasive objects in the mouth.
One possibility stood out: betel nuts.
The betel nut
Despite its name, the betel nut is not actually a nut. It is the seed of the Areca catechu palm. Today, areca nuts are consumed across parts of South and Southeast Asia and the Pacific. They are often prepared with betel leaf and slaked lime to make a chew known as betel quid.
The active compound of particular interest is arecoline, a substance that acts on the nervous system and can produce stimulation and other psychoactive effects.
The ancient practice may have been simpler than the modern preparation. Rather than making a quid, the researchers suggest that people may have sucked on whole betel nuts.
Could sucking a nut really have an effect?
The researchers investigated whether arecoline could be released from betel nuts through contact with saliva. Their experiments indicated that compounds could leach from the nut, making exposure through sucking plausible. Laboratory work also explored how the released compound interacts with human receptors.
This offers a possible explanation for the dental evidence, but it does not prove exactly what the prehistoric individuals did. Tooth wear is indirect evidence, and the interpretation remains a hypothesis rather than a chemically confirmed identification of betel residue on the teeth.
Medicine, pleasure — or both?
Why were Ice Age people doing it? The answer is uncertain. The researchers suggest that relief from toothache may have been one motivation. Areca can produce sensations in the mouth that users may find stimulating or numbing.
But the psychoactive effects may also have been desirable. There could have been social, cultural or ritual reasons for using the plant that have left no clear trace in the archaeological record.
Modern areca use is associated with serious health risks, including oral cancer, particularly when combined with betel quid ingredients such as tobacco. Its long history should not be mistaken for evidence that it is safe.
Before farming
Perhaps the most significant aspect of the discovery is its proposed age. The oldest individual lived during the Ice Age, long before agriculture transformed human societies.
One often-cited earlier example of psychoactive consumption is fermented barley beer at Raqefet Cave in the Levant, associated with people who lived around 13,000 years ago. If the Sulawesi interpretation is correct, it would push evidence for habitual use of a psychoactive plant much further back.
How old is the human search for altered states?
Humans have probably experimented with plants for as long as they have been able to observe their effects. Some plants relieve pain; others cause illness. Some stimulate, sedate or alter perception.
A curious forager did not need modern chemistry to discover that a particular plant could change how they felt. They needed only to notice what happened and remember it.
The Sulawesi discovery does not establish the first time humans ever used a psychoactive substance. It may represent the oldest evidence currently identified for a repeated practice of this kind — and even that interpretation remains open to further testing.
A habit that survived thousands of years
Modern betel use gives the discovery another dimension. Areca products are still consumed by millions of people across Asia and the Pacific, although preparation varies widely. We cannot assume that today’s practices descend directly from the behaviour suggested by the Sulawesi teeth, but the comparison is striking.
The evidence in our mouths
Archaeologists often search for ancient drugs in pottery, pipes, seeds, residues and burial objects. Here, a possible clue was preserved in something much more personal: the teeth of people who died thousands of years ago.
Their worn enamel may be recording a behaviour that would otherwise have vanished. Perhaps the human relationship with psychoactive plants is not a recent development associated with civilisation. Perhaps it reaches back into the Ice Age, when hunter-gatherers were still discovering what the natural world could do to the human body and mind.
