Oxygen is one of the most common elements in the Universe, and almost all of it was forged inside stars. When stars die, they return some of that material to space, enriching the gas from which future generations of stars and planets can form. But observations of nearby dwarf galaxies have uncovered a puzzle: many appear to contain far less oxygen than astronomers’ models predict.
A study using the Hubble Space Telescope examined 37 nearby dwarf galaxies and found that these small systems retain only a fraction of the oxygen their stars should have produced. The result provides a new test of how galaxies grow, evolve and exchange material with the space around them.
Small galaxies, big questions
Dwarf galaxies contain anywhere from a few thousand to hundreds of millions of stars. That is a huge range, but even the largest are small compared with the Milky Way, which contains hundreds of billions of stars. Their relatively weak gravitational pull makes dwarf galaxies particularly useful laboratories for studying how material escapes from galaxies.
Oxygen is a practical element to track. It is produced in large quantities by massive stars and can be measured through characteristic light emitted by gas. Because it is relatively easy to detect, it acts as a tracer for the distribution of heavier elements more generally.
The research team, led by scientists including Kristen McQuinn, used Hubble observations to resolve individual stars in the galaxies and reconstruct aspects of their star-formation histories. The analysis also drew on data from NASA’s retired Spitzer Space Telescope and radio observations from the Very Large Array and the Australia Telescope Compact Array.
The oxygen that should have been there
Computer simulations predict that galaxies in this mass range should retain more of the oxygen produced by their stars than the observations indicate. The mismatch suggests that a substantial amount has been driven out of the galaxies by energetic processes.
The leading explanation is a combination of stellar feedback and galactic winds. Massive stars emit intense radiation and powerful streams of particles. When they end their lives as supernovae, the explosions inject enormous amounts of energy into surrounding gas. In a small galaxy, this activity can help propel hot, oxygen-rich material beyond the galaxy’s gravitational grasp.
The new results indicate that these processes may be more effective at removing oxygen from low-mass galaxies than many existing models assume. The finding does not mean the oxygen has vanished. It has been displaced, but exactly where all of it ends up remains an open question.
Beyond the visible galaxy
Galaxies do not end neatly at the edge of their visible stars. They are surrounded by diffuse reservoirs of gas, often called the circumgalactic medium. Beyond that lies the intergalactic medium, the thin material between galaxies. Oxygen expelled by stellar winds may accumulate in these regions, mix with other gas or be carried farther away.
Earlier work on larger, Milky Way-like galaxies had already shown that substantial quantities of oxygen can be found outside their bright stellar discs. The new dwarf-galaxy study extends the question to systems with weaker gravity, where the escape of enriched gas may be more pronounced.
Determining whether the missing oxygen remains in a surrounding halo or has travelled much farther is difficult. The gas can be extremely diffuse and faint, making it challenging to observe directly. Future measurements across different environments and galaxy masses will help establish where the elements have gone.
Why the result matters
The distribution of oxygen and other heavy elements influences the evolution of galaxies. These elements can cool gas, affect how new stars form and eventually become part of planets. The material expelled from one galaxy can also enrich the environment from which another generation of galaxies develops.
If simulations underestimate how efficiently small galaxies lose their metals, astronomers may need to revise their models of galaxy formation. The result could help explain why dwarf galaxies often have lower chemical abundances than expected, and how the wider Universe became enriched over billions of years.
A missing-element mystery, not a missing-element miracle
The observations do not challenge the basic understanding of how stars manufacture oxygen. Instead, they reveal that the journey of those atoms after they are created is more complicated than some models predict. The oxygen is missing from the galaxies’ inventories, not from the Universe.
Hubble’s contribution is especially valuable because the galaxies are close enough for astronomers to study their individual stars and reconstruct their histories. The next step is to map the faint gas around them and determine how far the stellar winds have carried the elements.
Sources and further reading
- NASA: Hubble uncovers the case of missing oxygen in nearby dwarf galaxies, 2 November 2026.
- Space Telescope Science Institute: GLOW study announcement, 2 November 2026.
- NASA Hubble mission.
The study identifies a substantial shortfall in oxygen retained by the galaxies. The precise destination of all the expelled material is not yet known.
